Fancy Pants woke up yesterday believing he understood American elections.
Candidates run. Voters choose. Somebody wins. Somebody loses. Everyone spends the next two years explaining what the voters were “really saying.”
Then Alaska finished counting.
Democrat Mary Peltola defeated Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in the final unresolved Senate race of the midterms, giving Democrats a 56-44 majority after flipping nine Republican-held seats. It was their biggest midterm Senate gain in nearly seventy years. Democrats also picked up dozens of House seats, meaning voters had already delivered Washington a political message roughly equivalent to throwing a sofa through the front window.
Fancy Pants was prepared to analyze all of that until he learned there had been another Dan Sullivan on the ballot.
He slowly removed his glasses.
“Another Dan Sullivan?”
Janet nodded.
“Same election?”
“Yes.”
“Same office?”
“Yes.”
“Different Dan?”
“Apparently.”
Fancy Pants walked outside and stared silently at a tree for several minutes.
The second candidate, retired teacher Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., finished third in the primary and advanced to the general election. Allegations later surfaced that people connected to Peltola’s campaign had helped recruit him to confuse voters. Peltola denied knowing anything about it. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. denied working with her campaign. The Justice Department launched an investigation anyway, because once your federal election contains multiple Dan Sullivans, somebody eventually has to bring in lawyers.
Marvin was impressed.
“This changes everything.”
“How?”
“We have been wasting our time trying to persuade voters.”
Fancy Pants looked concerned.
Marvin continued. “Suppose Janet runs for town council. We simply find another Janet.”
“We already have Whitney.”
“She becomes Janet.”
“That seems unethical.”
Marvin shrugged. “Then we launch an investigation into ourselves.”
The flock immediately began brainstorming future campaigns.
Bruce suggested running two Mitch McConnells.
Frankie proposed seventy-three different people named Ted Cruz.
Simone argued that the most efficient strategy would simply be to rename every candidate “Undecided,” thereby capturing the largest demographic in American politics.
Fancy Pants reminded everyone that there was no proof the Peltola campaign orchestrated the second Sullivan candidacy.
“Fine,” Marvin said. “Then democracy invented this organically, which is somehow better.”
The sheep turned back to the election results. Democrats had swept through states that had seemed politically unreachable only months earlier. Alaska. Mississippi. Kansas. Texas. South Carolina. Voters had reshuffled Congress with the enthusiasm of someone violently shaking an Etch A Sketch.
Yet the flock remained obsessed with Alaska because America had somehow managed to transform one of its most important Senate races into the political equivalent of receiving a wedding invitation from two cousins named Michael.
Fancy Pants began imagining the ballot.
Dan Sullivan
Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.
Mary Peltola
Other
Seriously, Which Dan Sullivan?
Janet reminded him that Alaska uses ranked-choice voting.
This made Fancy Pants even happier.
“So voters could rank the Dan Sullivans?”
“Yes.”
“One Dan Sullivan above the other Dan Sullivan?”
“Yes.”
“And the government is investigating whether people might have been confused?”
“Yes.”
Fancy Pants smiled.
America had finally perfected democracy.
Voters could now choose their preferred candidate, their second-choice candidate, and, when necessary, their preferred Dan Sullivan.
By sundown, Marvin had changed his legal name to Dan Sullivan.
He said he wanted to keep his options open.



If you look at the ranked choice result, Dan Sullivan Jr finished 4th overall.
In the 2024 Washington state primary election the Republicans recruited three Washington state residents named Bob Ferguson to run for governor. Also on the ballot for governor was Democrat and Washington state Attorney General Bob Ferguson. That meant that there was a total of four Bob Fergusons running for governor. The problem was that it is against Washington state law to run for an office for the purpose of confusing the voters. The state threatened the bogus Fergusons with violation of state law and they quickly dropped out of the race. The Democrat Bob Ferguson easily won the election for governor. Maybe Alaska should concern a similar law.